Circumcision complications

Drs say complications are rare. NewsMedia says complications are rare. Families say complications are rare. Consent forms say complications are rare. Medical books and websites say complications are rare.
However, rare complications are pretty scary to the parents and children they affect.
Rare is not rare enough when it is your child.
Infant/child Circumcision is unnecessary surgery on a healthy child. The foreskin is not an issue, disease or defect.































Guggie Daly: removal of random body parts due to parental preference.

guggie daly:

“Ok I know we have about half a dozen boys or so in this group and I was on another forum talking about fingernail removal. Joseph has all his fingernails removed. I believe it is cleaner and DH says that he is happy and has never had a problem with loss of tactile sensation anything like that. Plus DH is so in charge of writing so no awkward questions about looking different then daddy.

So I was wondering how many of the other boys here had their fingernails removed at birth? If you decided for it was it just a religious or hygiene thing or was there another reason? If you decided against it will you support your son if he decides he wants it later because he’s a minority in English class or whatever? I know that this is becoming less of a rarity but still.

Those who have girls this year but have boys and those that are planning to have more babies please chime in on your feelings too.”

“I have two boys and removed the eyelids on both. I honestly was ambivalent about it. I’d read opinions on both sides, and wasn’t swayed either way, so I left it up to dh, since he was the one with experience in that area. Dh had his eyelids removed and wanted the boys the same too, so that’s the direction we went. I know plenty of people who have passed on eyelid removal, and I respect that.

“We’re pretty much in the same boat as Rudi. I was also pretty ambivilent and had no opinions either way. DH had a Cholecystectomy and thought that Alex should have one, too, so we went with that.

I talked to my OB about it and she said that SHE would be the one doing the procedure because it’s considered “surgery” so only a surgeon could do it. They don’t let just anybody perform Cholecystectomies at that hospital so I felt very comfortable with her handling him.

But I also know plenty of moms who opted to pass on the gallbladder removal and that’s fine, too. To each his own–literally.”

“Both of my boys are missing ears. I took off their ears for both of them because I felt that it is cleaner, and I never had any other thoughts of keeping ears on my children.”

“We decided both girls would be circ’d too. The wife is too. We actually never even questioned having it done. Our peds did both girls.”


Circumcision injuries, complications, pain

Below are excerpts and links. The links are in blue.

Elma cream not indicated for use on newborns or the genital area of a child under a year old

emla information insert
Use on the skin prior to procedures such as needle insertion and minor skin surgery
(adults and children older than 1 year):


Genitourinary injuries in the newborn.

Patel HI, Moriarty KP, Brisson PA, Feins NR.
J Pediatr Surg. 2001 Jan;36(1):235-9.

Division of Pediatric Surgery, The Floating Hospital for Children, Boston, MA, USA.

BACKGROUND: Circumcisions and cesarian sections are common procedures. Although complications to the newborn child fortunately are rare, it is important to emphasize the potential significance of this problem and its frequent iatrogenic etiology. The authors present 7 cases of genitourinary trauma in newborns, including surgical management and follow-up.

METHODS: The authors relate 7 recent cases of genitourinary trauma in newborns from a children’s hospital in a major metropolitan area.

RESULTS: Case 1 and 2: Two infants suffered degloving injuries to both the prepuce and penile shaft from a Gomco clamp. Successful full-thickness skin grafting using the previously excised foreskin was used in 1 child. Case 3, 4, and 5: A Mogen clamp caused glans injuries in 3 infants. In 2, hemorrhage from the severed glans was controlled with topical epinephrine; the glans healed with a flattened appearance. Another infant sustained a laceration ventrally, requiring a delayed modified meatal advancement glanoplasty to correct the injury. Case 6: A male infant suffered a ventral slit and division of the ventral urethra before placement of a Gomco clamp. Formal hypospadias repair was required. Case 7: An emergent cesarean section resulted in a grade 4-perineal laceration in a female infant. The vaginal tear caused by the surgeon’s finger, extended up to the posterior insertion of the cervix and into the rectum. The infant successfully underwent an emergent multilayered repair.

CONCLUSIONS: Genitourinary trauma in the newborn is rare but often necessitates significant surgical intervention. Circumcision often is the causative event. There has been only 1 prior report of a perineal injury similar to case 7, with a fatal outcome.

warning of injuries

This letter is to alert you to the potential for injury from two commonly used circumcision clamps, the Gomco®/gomco-type and Mogen®/mogen-type clamps. Both are widely used during circumcision to remove the foreskin while protecting the glans penis.
Although research suggests that circumcision is generally a safe procedure, we are concerned that some serious device-related complications have occurred. We received 105 reports of injuries involving circumcision clamps between July 1996 and January 20001. These have included laceration, hemorrhage, penile amputation, and urethral damage.
We are providing recommendations below that can help avoid these complications.

pain meds not truly effective in many infant circumcisions

RESULTS: Dorsal nerve blocks were judged to be fully effective in over 70% of cases. Neither Mogen nor PlastiBell was associated with greater pain per 3-minute time period, but the PlastiBell technique on average took nearly twice as long as the Mogen procedure (20 vs 12 minutes). We judged that 60% of the infants had pain or discomfort associated with the procedure that was excessive. Residents and interns universally preferred the Mogen technique over the PlastiBell because of the former’s simplicity.

Pain, discomfort, and behavioral changes are well documented during neonatal circumcision;9,10,11,12 however, there are few studies comparing methods and procedures used for circumcisions.13 In this study, we measured duration and intensity of pain with a simple behavioral scale after randomizing infants to one of two techniques ¾ Mogen or PlastiBell. Our presumption was that the procedure of shortest duration would be the least painful granted the amount of pain per unit time was similar with each technique. Although circumcision is usually a rapid procedure in the hands of skilled operators,13 no studies have compared the amount of time required by trainees to perform different techniques.

plastibell complication with pic


circumcision complications with photos

pictures of the procedure of circumcision and pics of some complications

pictures of the plastibell being done

vocabulary of circumcision

——– in the end it doesn’t matter if almost all circumcisions on children come out without complication. It doesn’t matter if it is mostly safe. What if it is your child with the complication? What if it is your child that is seriously harmed? These are elective surgeries… ELECTIVE, which means one serious complication is one too many on an u consenting, healthy, innocent, helpless child.